Are Employers Asking for Too Much? The Problem with the Perfect Candidate
Every employer wants to find the right person for their business. Someone with the right skills, experience, qualifications and attitude, but have we reached a point where we’re expecting candidates to tick every single box?
Five years’ experience, specific industry knowledge, multiple qualifications, experience with particular systems, excellent communication skills and a long list of other requirements.
There’s nothing wrong with knowing what you’re looking for. In fact, having a clear understanding of what a role requires is an important part of successful recruitment, however, when does a job specification become a wish list that very few people could realistically meet?
How many good candidates are employers overlooking because they don’t look perfect on paper?
The Search for the Perfect Candidate
Recruitment can be challenging, particularly when businesses need someone who can step into a role and make an immediate contribution.
Employers understandably want to minimise risk, reduce training time and find someone who can hit the ground running. The reality is that the perfect candidate rarely exists.
Someone might have excellent technical experience but lack knowledge of a particular software package. Another candidate might have worked in a different industry but possess highly relevant transferable skills.
Then there’s the individual who doesn’t have every qualification listed but has the right attitude, practical ability and willingness to learn. Should these people automatically be ruled out?
In some cases, employers may be narrowing their talent pool without even realising it.
Essential Skills or Just Nice to Have?
One of the most important questions employers should ask when recruiting is whether every requirement on their job description is genuinely essential.
There’s a big difference between something a candidate must know before starting and something they could reasonably learn once they’re in the role.
For example, does someone really need experience using one specific software system, or would experience with similar systems and the ability to learn quickly be sufficient?
Does a candidate need five years of experience, or could someone with two years of strong, relevant experience do the job equally well? Could someone from a different sector bring valuable knowledge, a fresh perspective and skills that would benefit the business?
Of course, some positions require specific qualifications, certifications or technical competencies for legal, regulatory or safety reasons. These requirements should never be compromised.
Allowing flexibility is possible, separating essential criteria from desirable ones can make a significant difference.
Are We Overlooking Transferable Skills?
Transferable skills are often underestimated. Someone who has worked in manufacturing may have experience in quality control, health and safety, problem solving, teamwork and meeting demanding production targets.
An individual from hospitality might bring excellent customer service, communication, organisation and the ability to remain calm under pressure.
A person with a background in administration may have developed strong planning, coordination and systems skills that could transfer into several different roles.
Yet candidates can sometimes struggle to get an interview simply because their previous job title or industry doesn’t match what’s written on the job specification.
Experience doesn’t become irrelevant just because it was gained in a different environment. Employers willing to look beyond job titles may discover candidates they wouldn’t otherwise have considered.
Experience Matters, BUT So Does Attitude
Qualifications and experience are important, and in many roles they’re absolutely necessary, however, they’re not the only things that determine whether someone will be successful.
Reliability, motivation, communication, problem solving and a willingness to learn can be equally valuable. Someone might have ten years of experience but struggle to adapt to change.
Another candidate might have less experience but demonstrate enthusiasm, initiative and a genuine commitment to developing their skills. Neither should automatically be considered better than the other.
The question is whether the individual has the ability, approach and potential to succeed in that particular role. Sometimes, that means looking beyond what’s written on their CV.
Could Job Descriptions Be Putting Good Candidates Off?
It’s not just employers who are affected by lengthy lists of requirements.
Candidates can be discouraged from applying when they see a job advert containing an extensive list of essential skills and qualifications.
Someone who meets most of the criteria may decide not to apply because they’re missing one or two requirements, and that could mean an employer never gets the opportunity to meet someone who might have been an excellent addition to their team.
A good job advert should be clear about what the role involves, what is genuinely required and where there is room for development.
Being realistic doesn’t mean lowering standards. It means understanding which standards matter most.
Training Should Be Part of the Conversation
One of the reasons employers look for candidates with every required skill is the understandable desire to avoid lengthy training periods.
For smaller businesses in particular, time and resources can be limited. It’s worth considering whether a relatively small investment in training could open the door to a much wider pool of candidates.
Could an experienced employee provide mentoring? Could a new recruit learn a particular system during their first few weeks? Could someone with strong foundational skills develop the additional technical knowledge they need?
Training isn’t always an expensive, formal programme. It can simply be about providing the right support and allowing someone the opportunity to develop.
When businesses invest in their employees, they also create opportunities for growth and progression.
Five Questions Employers Should Ask Before Advertising a Vacancy
Before publishing your next job advert, it may be worth asking:
- Are all our essential requirements genuinely essential? Could some be moved into the desirable category?
- Are we asking for experience that the role doesn’t actually need? Is the number of years important, or is the candidate’s ability to do the job what really matters?
- Could someone from another industry succeed in this position? Are there transferable skills worth considering?
- What could we realistically train someone to do? Would a little support allow us to consider a wider range of candidates?
- Are we recruiting for what the business needs today and tomorrow? Could someone with the right potential grow into the role and contribute over the longer term?
These questions won’t apply to every vacancy, but they may help you approach recruitment with a slightly different perspective.
Finding the Right Person, Not Just the Perfect CV
Successful recruitment isn’t about finding someone who looks impressive on paper. It’s about finding someone who can do the job, contribute to the business and develop within the role.
Sometimes that person will have exactly the experience and qualifications you’re looking for. Other times, they might bring something you hadn’t originally considered.
And while employers should never compromise on genuinely essential skills, being open-minded about how candidates have developed their experience can lead to better hiring decisions.
The aim shouldn’t be to lower expectations. It should be to make sure those expectations are realistic, relevant and genuinely necessary.
Across Scotland, employers are continually looking for people with the right skills and experience.
At the same time, there are candidates looking for opportunities to prove themselves, develop their careers or move into a different industry.
Perhaps there’s an opportunity to bring those two groups closer together by taking a more flexible approach to recruitment.
Because sometimes, the right person for the job isn’t the one who ticks every box. It’s the one who has the ability, attitude and potential to make a real difference.





